Michael Packard's story of being swallowed briefly by a humpback whale as he was diving for lobster off Provincetown, at the tip of Cape Cod, Friday went viral quickly.
The story is riveting: "He was biting down on me, biting down on my legs. I felt lots of pressure and just getting twisted and turned every direction."
It's a Jonah-like story. But is it a whale of a tale? Or a fish story?
Robert Kaplow was visiting Provincetown from New Jersey. "I heard about it yesterday and I remember thinking, could this possibly be true?”
Get Boston local news, weather forecasts, lifestyle and entertainment stories to your inbox. Sign up for NBC Boston’s newsletters.
Dr. Peter Corkeron of the New England Aquarium was shocked when he heard.
"My reaction was just ... what!?" he said.
Corkeron is the head of the New England Aquarium's Marine Mammal Conservation Program and said, “Being accidentally swallowed by a feeding whale ... that just never happens. That's really incredibly unusual.'
More Whale News
But he also said the way humpbacks feed -- opening their huge jaws 90 degrees and taking in hundreds of gallons of water and food -- make it possible.
"I imagine the whale had this, like, 'Oh my goodness' moment and probably got rid of him as quickly as it could," Corkeron said.
Which sounds right to some, like Kaplow.
"Having gone whale watching here in Provincetown, you see the physical enormity of the whale. I mean, they're the size of a bus and you say, okay, I guess it could happen."
Sign up for our Breaking news newsletter to get the most urgent news stories in your inbox.
Others, like Joanne Keating, still have questions.
"I first believed it but, thinking about it, the fact that he didn't have very many injuries and didn't seem traumatized enough ... so I'm skeptical because of that," she said.
The New York Post published an article over the weekend quoting a doctor at the hospital where Packard was treated saying, without giving their name, that it was hard to believe someone who rose from 45 feet underwater to the surface so quickly wouldn't suffer an injury from the quick change in pressure.
Michael Packard did not return a call Monday to see what he has to say about the skeptics.
He did tell reporters Friday that he was surprised he hadn't suffered any ear damage from the change in pressure as he quickly ascended inside the whale.
Asher Klein contributed to this report.