New Rules to Prevent Oscars Envelope Gaffe - NBC10 Boston
National & International News
The day’s top national and international news

New Rules to Prevent Oscars Envelope Gaffe

In the months that followed, PwC met with the academy many times to come up with new protocols and safeguards to prevent such a blunder in the future

Find NBC Boston in your area

Channel 10 on most providers

Channel 15, 60 and 8 Over the Air

    processing...

    NEWSLETTERS

    Oscar Accountants Talk Mistake Protocols Before Show

    Brian Cullinan and Martha Ruiz are the two accountants from PwC who controlled the envelopes at the 89th Academy Awards. Before the big event, they talked about their job, which Ruiz called a "big responsibility." She added that they even memorize the winners so they can make sure the right names are called onstage. (Published Monday, Feb. 27, 2017)

    After taking responsibility for the epic best picture flub at the Oscars last year, Tim Ryan of PwC got down to business.

    He grilled the partners who made the gaffe, then personally reached out to the dozens of people affected by it: The show's producers, presenters and stage managers, as well as the filmmakers behind "La La Land" and "Moonlight."

    In the months that followed, PwC met with the academy many times to come up with new protocols and safeguards to prevent such a blunder in the future. Ryan revealed six new reforms to The Associated Press. They include a new process in which the celebrity presenter will confirm they have the correct envelope before stepping onstage, PwC partners attending rehearsals, as well as measures to quickly correct any mistake.

    Last year's mistake happened when a PwC partner mistakenly handed an envelope for the best actress winner category, which went to Emma Stone in "La La Land," to the presenters of the best picture category, Warren Beatty and Faye Dunaway. That resulted in "La La Land" being briefly named best picture, before one of that film's producers revealed the error and that "Moonlight" had in fact won.

    "One of the most disappointing things to me was all the great work that had been done, not only last year but over the last 83 years, around accuracy, confidentiality integrity of that process," he said. "And where we got it wrong was on the handing over of the envelope."

    Ryan said Oscar voting procedures and the tabulation of nominees and winners won't change. Instead, reforms focus on envelope rituals.

    Ryan said he will be personally involved with Oscar operations this year as PwC's U.S. chairman and senior partner.

    'Tonight': Anthony Mackie's First Time Smoking Weed

    [NATL] 'Tonight': Anthony Mackie's First Time Smoking Weed Got Him Chased by a Moose

    Anthony Mackie reminds Jimmy Fallon of the time they ate sushi with Mick Jagger at the Met Ball until 7 a.m., describes his first weed experience, which ended with him getting chased by a moose, and gives a brilliant recap of "Avengers: Infinity War."

    (Published Saturday, April 21, 2018)

    Other changes include:

    — The addition of a third balloting partner, who will sit with Oscar producers in the show's control room. Just like the balloting partners stationed on either side of the Dolby Theatre stage, this person will have a complete set of winners' envelopes and commit the winners to memory. "Think of it as a safety control," Ryan said.

    — The two partners who worked on last year's Academy Awards have been replaced, though Ryan confirms that both still work for PwC. The new stage-side partners overseeing the envelopes will include Rick Rosas, who previously worked in that post for 14 years, and colleague Kimberly Bourdon from the company's Los Angeles office.

    'Tonight': Karate Piñata with Anthony Mackie & Ralph Macchio

    [NATL] 'Tonight': Karate Piñata with Anthony Mackie and Karate Kid Ralph Macchio

    Jimmy Fallon challenges Anthony Mackie and Ralph Macchio, who brings his "Karate Kid" expertise, to face off in a game that combines the skill of karate with the fun of a piñata party.

    (Published Saturday, April 21, 2018)

    — A new formal procedure is in place for when envelopes are handed over. Both the celebrity presenter and a stage manager will confirm that they've been given the correct envelope for the category they are about to present. (Last year's gaffe occurred when the PwC representative accidentally gave presenters the envelope for best actress rather than best picture.)

    — All three balloting partners will attend show rehearsals and practice what to do if something goes wrong. "Because, as you're well aware, it took a long time to respond last year when there was a mistake that we made," Ryan said. "So we're formally practicing the what-ifs."

    The final change is one the academy immediately instituted last year: PwC partners are prohibited from using cellphones or social media during the show.

    'Tonight': Tina Fey Surprises Fans While They Thank Her

    [NATL] 'Tonight': Tina Fey Surprises Fans While They Thank Her

    Tina Fey surprises superfans while they film video messages to her, sharing how her career and "Mean Girls" impacted them, and Jimmy Fallon surprises Tina with a heartfelt message of his own.

    (Published Friday, April 20, 2018)

    "Our singular focus will be on the show and delivering the correct envelopes," Ryan said.

    Besides tabulating votes for Oscar nominees and winners, PwC handles much of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences' accounting, including audits and taxes.

    Film academy chief Dawn Hudson said that after reviewing the relationship between the two organizations, and given that the voting and secrecy around the Academy Awards were never compromised, the academy chalked up the envelope mistake to simple human error.

    'Tonight': Superlatives 2018 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs

    [NATL] 'Tonight': Superlatives 2018 NHL Stanley Cup Playoffs

    Jimmy Fallon hands out superlatives to the NHL players competing in the playoffs for the Stanley Cup.

    (Published Friday, April 20, 2018)

    "Still, it was a big human error, and it was a very public human error," Hudson said.

    Ultimately, academy officials and board members decided not to "throw out 83 years of flawless partnership over this, while huge, one human error," she said, adding that PwC helped build the digital voting system the academy has been using for the Oscars in recent years.

    "Let me tell you, I don't think this error will ever happen again or would happen again," said Hudson, who was watching from the audience as the flub seemed to occur in slow motion onstage. "We put in a lot of protocols to make sure it won't, but I don't think it will anyway. I think everyone will be very focused on getting that right."

    'Tonight': Wheel of Freestyle With Letitia Wright

    [NATL] 'Tonight': Wheel of Freestyle With 'Black Panther's' Letitia Wright

    Letitia Wright of "Black Panther" and The Roots' Black Thought take turns working three random words they've never seen before into a freestyle rap (plus a surprise freestyle from Jimmy Fallon).

    (Published Thursday, April 19, 2018)

    Ryan is similarly confident.

    "My nature, just as a person, is healthy paranoia. But I also know in my head that we haven't left any step undone. We owe that to the academy," he said. "While I feel very, very good about all the work that's been done and the attention to detail that's in place, our job doesn't end until that curtain closes."

    Nominations for the 90th Academy Awards will be announced Tuesday. Winners will be revealed at the ceremony on March 4.

    'Tonight': Hashtag #StonerStories

    [NATL] 'Tonight': Hashtag #StonerStories

    Jimmy Fallon reads his favorite tweets with the hashtag #StonerStories.

    (Published Thursday, April 19, 2018)