- Digital media companies including BuzzFeed, Vice, Vox Media and Bustle Digital Group are sharpening their focus on core strengths.
- The smaller media companies' emphasis on differentiation echoes a larger media movement to cut costs and focus on brands.
- Executives are split on whether the digital media industry will have another wave of significant consolidation, especially as companies look increasingly different from one another.
When a marriage or an engagement fails, it's common for the participants to take time to work on themselves.
That's where the digital media industry finds itself today.
After years of focusing on consolidating to better compete with Google and Facebook for digital advertising dollars, many of the most well-known digital media companies have abandoned consolidation efforts to concentrate on differentiation.
Get Boston local news, weather forecasts, lifestyle and entertainment stories to your inbox. Sign up for NBC Boston’s newsletters.
"What you're finding is companies are trying to find a non-substitutable core," said Jonathan Miller, the CEO of Integrated Media, which specializes in digital media investments. "The era of trying to put these companies together is over, and I don't think it's coming back."
A 90% decline in BuzzFeed shares since the company went public in 2021, a failed sales process from Vice, the collapse of special purpose acquisition companies, and a choppy advertising market have made digital media executives rethink their companies' futures. For the moment, executives have decided that more concentrated investment is better than attempts to gain scale.
"Right now, everyone's trying to get through a tougher market by focusing on their strengths," BuzzFeed CEO Jonah Peretti said in an interview with CNBC. "We're in this period now where we should just focus on innovating for the future and building more efficient, stronger, better companies."
What's happening in the digital media space echoes trends from the biggest media companies, including Netflix, Disney and Warner Bros. Discovery. After losing nearly half their market values, or more, in 2022, those companies have emphasized what makes them different, whether it be distribution, brand or quality of programming, after years of global expansion and mega-mergers. Disney CEO Bob Iger said the word "brand" more than 25 times at a Morgan Stanley media conference this month.
"I think brands matter," Iger said. "The more choice people have, the more important brands become because of what they convey to consumers."
Making strategic decisions based on consumer demand rather than investor pressure is a pivot for the industry, said Bryan Goldberg, CEO of Bustle Digital Group, which has acquired and developed a number of brands and sites aimed at women, including Nylon, Scary Mommy, Romper and Elite Daily.
"Too many of the mergers were driven by investor needs as opposed to consumer needs," Goldberg said in an interview.
The rollup dream's rise and fall
From late 2018 to early 2022, the digital media industry had a shared goal. Pushed by venture capitalist and private equity investors who had made sizeable investments in the industry during the 2010s, companies such as BuzzFeed, Vice, Vox Media, Group Nine, and Bustle Digital Group, or BDG, were talking to each other, in various combinations, about merging to gain scale.
"If BuzzFeed and five of the other biggest companies were combined into a bigger digital media company, you would probably be able to get paid more money," Peretti told The New York Times in November 2018, kicking off a multiyear effort to consolidate.
The rationale was twofold. First, digital media companies needed more scale to compete with Facebook and Google for digital advertising dollars. Adding sites and brands under one corporate umbrella would boost overall eyeballs for advertisers. Cost-cutting from M&A synergies was an added benefit for investors.
Second, longtime shareholders wanted to exit their investments. Large legacy media companies such as Disney and Comcast's NBCUniversal invested hundreds of millions in digital media in the early and mid-2010s. Disney invested more than $400 million in Vice. NBCUniversal put a similar amount into BuzzFeed. By the end of the decade, after seeing the value of those investments fall, legacy media companies made it clear to digital media executives that they weren't interested in being acquirers.
With no strategic buyer available, merging with each other using publicly traded stock could give VC and PE shareholders a chance to cash out of investments that were well past the standard hold time of seven years. Digital media companies eyed special purpose acquisition companies — also known as SPACs or blank-check companies — as a way to go public quickly. The popularity of SPACs picked up steam in 2020 and peaked in 2021.
Deal flow accelerated. Vox Media acquired New York Magazine in September 2019. About a week later, Vice announced it had acquired Refinery29, a digital media company focused on younger women. BuzzFeed bought news aggregator and blog HuffPost in 2020 and then acquired digital publisher Complex Networks in 2021 as part of a SPAC transaction to go public. Vox Media and Group Nine agreed to a merger later that year.
BuzzFeed, generally thought by industry executives at the time to have the strongest balance sheet with the best growth narrative, successfully went public via SPAC in December 2021. Shares immediately tanked, falling 24% in their first week of trading. The coming weeks and months were even worse. BuzzFeed opened at $10 per share. The stock currently trades at about $1 — a 90% loss of value.
BuzzFeed's underwhelming performance coincided with the implosion of the SPAC market in early 2022 as interest rates rose. Other companies that planned to follow BuzzFeed shut down their efforts to go public completely. Vice tried and failed. Now it's trying for the second time in two years to find a buyer. BDG and Vox Media, meanwhile, abandoned considerations to go public. Vox Media instead sold a 20% stake in itself in February to Penske Media, which owns Rolling Stone and Variety.
The industry turns inward
Consolidation was always a flawed strategy because digital media could never become big enough to compete with Facebook and Google, said Integrated Media's Miller.
"You have to have sufficient amount of scale to matter, but that's not a winning formula by itself," Miller said.
Vice's deal for Refinery29 is a prime example of a deal motivated by scale that lacked consumer rationale, said BDG's Goldberg.
"The digital media rollup has proven successful only when assets are thoughtfully combined with an eye toward consumers," Goldberg said. "In what world did Vice and Refinery29 make sense in combination?"
Vice is engaged in sale talks with a number of buyers that fall outside the digital media landscape, CNBC previously reported. It's also considering selling itself in pieces if there's more interest in parts of the company, such as its TV production assets and its ad agency, Virtue.
Vice is a cautionary tale of what happens to a digital media company when its brand loses luster, Miller said. Valued at $5.7 billion in 2017, Vice is now considering selling itself for around $500 million, according to people familiar with the matter, who asked not to be named because the sale discussions are private.
A Vice spokesperson declined to comment.
"In the old days of media, with TV networks, if you were down, you could revive yourself with a hit," said Miller. "In the internet age, everything is so easily substitutable. If Vice goes down, the audience just moves on to something else."
Companies such as BuzzFeed, Vox Media and BDG are now trying to find an enduring relevancy amid a myriad of information and entertainment options. BuzzFeed has chosen to lean in to artificial intelligence, touting new AI-generated quizzes and other content that fuses the work of staff writers with AI databases.
BDG has chosen to primarily target female audiences across lifestyle categories.
Vox Media has focused on journalism and information across a number of different verticals. That's a strategy that hasn't really changed even as the market has turned against digital media, allowing Vox Media CEO Jim Bankoff the opportunity to continue to hunt for deals. Just don't expect the partners to be Vice, BDG or BuzzFeed.
"We want to be the leading modern media company with the strongest portfolio of brands that serve their audiences on modern platforms — websites, podcasts, streaming services — while building franchises through multiple revenue streams," Bankoff said. "There's no doubt M&A is part of our playbook, and we expect it will continue to be in the future."
Finding an exit
While executives may be making strategy decisions with a sharper eye toward the consumer, the problem of finding an exit for investors remains. Differentiation may open up the pool of potential buyers beyond the media industry. BuzzFeed's emphasis on artificial intelligence could attract interest from technology platforms, for instance.
It's also possible that there will be an eventual second wave of peer-to-peer mergers. While Integrated Media's Miller doesn't expect a future industry rollup, BuzzFeed's Peretti hasn't closed the door on the concept if market conditions improve. As executives invest in fewer ideas and verticals, the end result could be healthier companies that are more attractive merger partners, he said.
"If everyone invests in what they're best at, if you put them back together, you'd have that diversified digital media company with real scale," Peretti said. "That helps drive commerce for all parts of a unified company. I think it's still possible."
Disclosure: Comcast's NBCUniversal is the parent company of CNBC.
WATCH: Axios' Sara Fischer on BuzzFeed's continuing struggles